This post is for old time radio nerds. I took a classic script,
A Shipment of Mute Fate, that was produced multiple times with different casts to give you an idea just how different the same story can be when different talents and time limits get involved.
If you just want to do a fast ompare, listen to two key segments of each episode. The first is at the beginning of each show (starting at about 1:00) where the narrator character (Chris Warner) walks up the gangplank and meets Mother Willis, then walks in to Captain Wood's office to discuss shipping the deadly Bushmaster. The second is the fight at the end (between 17 and 24 minutes into the show).
Listen for the following:
- The three main characters - their tone and apparent age.
- The sound fx - in the first segment it will be ambient harbor sounds, in the second it will be the cat and the snake's strikes.
- The narrator during the fight - the relative tenseness and rapidity of his delivery.
Some of the narrators are a bit too nonchalant for me (cough ... John Lund ... cough), as if they are working at being a 'cool' or trendy voice rather than thinking about how the character would be feeling at that moment in the story. And the sound effects. I'm not sure any of the cats sound realistic to me, but some are definitely better than others. As the years go on, it seems the effects proliferate. The harbor noises in the later episodes are certainly more notable than those in the earliest.
Note that time difference on the second segment! It usually comes around 23:00 but the Jack Webb episode is missing a bit of audio in the middle and Suspense scripts were condensed. The program times are listed in chronological order below (years in parenthesis) to illustrate how scripts were shortened to increase commercial time. This, of course, affects the story quite a bit, since the 1960 production is two-thirds as long as the 1948 program.
24:31 (1947)
29:14 (1948)
29:31 (1949)
29:30 (1950)
23:47 (1957)
20:42 (1960)
Escape #10
A Shipment of Mute Fate15 Oct 1947
19471015(010)_ESCP_AShipmentOfMuteFate(JackWebb).mp3AUDIO PROBLEM AT 13:12 - Unfortunately right at a key moment in the story. William N. Robson (producer, director), Martin Storm (author), Les Crutchfield (script), Jack Webb (Chris Warner), Raymond Lawrence (Captain Wood), D.J. Thompson (Mother Willis), Cy Feuer (music conceiver, conductor) - verified
Escape #34
A Shipment of Mute Fate28 Mar 1948
19480328(034)_ESCP_AShipmentOfMuteFate(HarryBartell).mp3Norman Macdonnell (director), Martin Storm (author), Les Crutchfield (script), Harry Bartell (Chris Warner), Berry Kroeger (Captain Wood), Peggy Weber (Mother Willis), Don Diamond, Sarah Selby, Frank Gerstle, David Light (effects), Wilbur Hatch (music) - verified
Escape #60
A Shipment of Mute Fate13 Mar 1949
19490313(060)_ESCP_AShipmentOfMuteFate(JohnLund).mp3Norman Macdonnell (director), Martin Storm (author), Les Crutchfield (script), John Lund (Chris Warner), Berry Kroeger (Captain Wood), Lois Corbett (Mother Willis), David Ellis, Don Diamond, Vivi Janis, Earl Kean & Gus Beys (effects), Lief Stevens (conductor) - verified
Escape #118
A Shipment of Mute Fate7 Jul 1950
19500707(118)_ESCP_AShipmentOfMuteFate(DavidEllis).mp3William N. Robson (producer, director), Martin Storm (author), Les Crutchfield (script), David Ellis (Chris Warner), William Conrad (Captain Wood), Sarah Selby (Mother Willis), David Light (Clara the cat), Verna Felton, Ted de Corsia, Harry Bartell, Paul Frees, Ivan Ditmars (music) - verified
Suspense #680
A Shipment of Mute Fate6 Jan 1957
19570106(680)_SUSP_AShipmentOfMuteFate(JackKelly).mp3Jack Kelly (Chris Warner) - verified (all other credits clipped)
Suspense #847
A Shipment of Mute Fate3 Apr 1960
19600403(847)_SUSP_AShipmentOfMuteFate(BernardGrant).mp3Martin Storm (author), Les Crutchfield (script), Bernard Grant (Chris Warner), Inga Swenson (Mother Willis), Ralph Bell, Bob Dryden, Frank Thomas Jr., Frank Milano - verified
Lachesis Muta, immortalized on a stamp